Education is a kind of continuing dialogue, and a dialogue assumes, in the nature of the case, different points of view.
Robert Hutchins 1899-1977

Friday, September 17, 2010

Rhetoric and Audience

I’m struggling this week trying to define what “good” rhetoric is versus “bad” rhetoric (“cookery” for Plato).

Aristotle defines rhetoric's function as "not simply to succeed in persuading but rather to discover the means of coming as near such successes as the circumstances of each particular case allow" (Herrick, p. 77). So that means that rhetors do not necessarily have to win people over, but they have to do the best they can given the situation to achieve this success. But where is that line? Who determines whether the situation only allows for a near success or that the rhetor is simply ineffective?

I keep mulling over the role of the audience and the expectations that are placed upon it; they should be engaged, thinking, participatory. Yet the assumptions Aristotle seems to make about an audience’s abilities don’t appear to give them that much credit. In Chapter 1 of Rhetoric, Aristotle discusses four reasons for the usefulness of rhetoric. The first two, however, seem to address assumptions about audience:

  • 1) all things equal, truth will prevail, but since all things are not equal, rhetors are important to "advocate" true and just ideas
  • 2) knowledge of audience is crucial as even true and just ideas will not be received if the audience's frame of mind does not match that of the rhetor

When the rhetor begins an argument, he or she has a goal-- to persuade the audience--and it seems to me that Aristotle sees the audience as less enlightened; it can't see what is "true and just" without guidance. Additionally, Aristotle's second point, that the message must match the mood, implies how easily an audience can be persuaded when the rhetor is in tune with his or her listeners. I suppose this should be obvious as only an elite few were trained rhetoricians in Aristotle's day, but I keep thinking about how we use rhetoric today and how the audience, in many circumstances, is as empty as many of our contemporary rhetors. But maybe it is not because people have become less “engaged” or less “enlightened;” from Aristotle’s viewpoint, the audience has always needed to be shown the way.

As an instructor, I have always recognized the importance of rhetoric and used it to “persuade” my students. And I make assumptions about these students, my audience. I assume they won’t see the truth without my guiding them. I do my best to “sync” our moods and divine common experiences to win them over. So I guess that just confirms my own assessment that I am more Sophistic than Platonic, but may Aristotle is too.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Are you more platonic or sophistic in the context of your belief systems and professional practices?

Tough question. When I was a master's student, I had an incredibly dynamic Shakespeare professor who was simply immersed in Plato. In everything we read, we saw the "Allegory of the Cave," and "The Myth of the Charioteer" could be applied to any protagonist's struggle with his soul. And I have to admit, I loved it. The idea of perfect forms and philosopher-kings was very appealing. However, the more removed I became from Dr. Warr, the harder it was to maintain the level of excitement and, quite frankly, buy-in of the Platonic ideals.

Today I have to say that I find myself much more pragmatic. Although I still like the ideas Plato puts forth in the "Allegory" and "Charioteer," I don't think that the Forms and perfect control are attainable, nor something worth striving for to the level Plato would approve. I guess I'm much more caught up in the practical--I think we need to do the best we can with what we've got.

In Plato's discussion of the four true arts of health, he states that the healthy soul resides in the people (or legislators for him) who have true knowledge of virtue and vice while the "unhealthy" soul resides in sophists, or people who are only concerned about themselves or their own interest groups. But I think Plato paints this picture too black and white; there's a middle ground that may not make us saints, but it does not make us self-serving either. This middle ground is determined through interaction and response to our audience.

As an instructor, if I followed Plato's teachings and only sought out his Truth, Forms, and Dialectic, I'd be talking to myself. By responding to my students and making adjustments for both their needs and the standards and benchmarks to which I am held accountable, I think we do okay. Do I adjust my teaching to be self-serving? I do like my job and I want to keep it--but I like to think that on most days, I make adjustments and accommodations because I like teaching, I enjoy students, and I want to make a difference. I wouldn't exactly call it virtuous, but I don't think that I need to be "restored" to health either.

So, although I am drawn to Plato, I have abandoned my infatuation with his ideals for a philosophy that can make a practical difference in the real world.

Friday, September 3, 2010

Rhetoric and Responsibility

This week's readings provided a framework for terminology and ideas that we will cover this semester. Even after a great class discussion, it's taking a bit of time to digest all we covered, but I think we did lay a solid foundation for future discussion. In addition to discussing the origins of rhetoric (or maybe acknowledgment or recognition of rhetoric) and the quick outline of rhetoric's evolution, one idea that stuck with me is how we use rhetoric and why the concept has such a negative connotation at times.

Just this morning while watching a news program, the talking heads were critiquing a politician's view as "empty rhetoric." They felt that his message had no real content, no value, yet the politician was successful. Is it the politician's fault that he knows what his constituents want to hear, and relying on ethos (but more likely pathos) delivers a message he has crafted to be well-received? On one level, the politician may be "abusing" rhetoric--turning it into the "foul and ugly" craft Plato describes. But our reading in Herrick points out the importance of looking at rhetoric as more than one-sided. He cites Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca who believe that
"audience has the major role in determining the quality of argument and the behavior of orators." That is to say, an ignorant or noncritical audience can be one cause of weak or unethical rhetoric, while a well-informed and critically minded audience demands that the rhetoric addressed to it be well reasoned and honestly presented (10).
So, although we may dislike the politician, if he is unchallenged and the audience is either ignorant, accepting, or indifferent, it should be held as responsible for the poor content as the rhetor. The audience, therefore, must have an active role in determining the content of the message, and, in the case of a politician, direction in which it wishes to be led or how it wishes to be represented.

This idea of responsibility and rhetoric may be a little too narrow-minded considering the vast amount of information we flew through this week, but I've always thought that the creator, the rhetor was the one in control of the message. Clearly he or she is the one who selects many aspects of a message, but the audience has (or should have) a much larger role than I would have thought. Rhetoric is clearly not a solitary endeavor.

Friday, August 27, 2010

5361 Assignment Suggestions

Lots of great assignment ideas were suggested in class last night. I'm afraid that I don't have much original to offer, but I'd like to throw in my support for a few that we discussed.

I like the idea of working on a larger project and reporting in stages--one that may have multimodal attributes. The first part of the project could reflect researched rhetorical foundations, possibly a traditional brief paper of sorts. The final project may inlcude a Prezi presentation or a document that would fit the guidelines for a Kairos-style project. Another approach for this type of project may be to create a website which would showcase the content.

Another assignment that interested me was creating a profile of one rhetorician, documenting his or her contribution or effect on contemporary rhetoric. Then, we could analyze an artifact(s) through the lens of the particular rhetorician.

A third possibility might compare or contrast similar content delivered in different media. How are the rhetorical situations different? How are persuasive strategies are used? What is the impact of the medium on the content and its efficacy?

Again, there were many good ideas generated in class last night. I look forward to the upcoming projects--whatever they may be!

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Style Revisited

I am still trying to create that "perfect" definition of style for my paper. This go-round replaces sprawl with a few nominalizations, but it is getting more concise.

Style is developed through a writer's effective selection and arrangement of ideas utilizing the appropriate technology to communicate effectively with a specific audience.

Still not happy, but working on it!

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Refer to high, middle, and low styles with what you read/worked on from the edited collection.

Lanham's chapter "High, Medium, and Low Styles" proved simultaneously enlightening and frustrating (at least for someone longing for just one concrete definition). As with much of what we have read this semester, Lanham provides guidelines, general rules, to assist readers in determining categories of style. He does provide a somewhat concrete list of characteristics of high and low style on page 164; however, the application of these traits is not nearly as neat as the columns in which they appear often causing the reader to struggle deciding which category a prose piece should fit. From Lanham's viewpoint, the fact that prose doesn't always fall easily into one category or the other may be good as he states that "it is generally agreed that the middle is the essential prose style. . . " (183).

The criteria Lanham puts forth to assess these three style categories provides a rough rubric with which to determine levels of style, but an equally important consideration is who applies the rubric. If we consider the characteristics of high and low style and strive for "the essential prose style," how do we recognize it when we see it? Lanham, again, provides subjective criteria for identifying middle style: "The middleness of the middle style will lie, for such a reader, in the expectedness of the style. . . . We must talk about the social substance that surrounds it, the historical pattern of expectation which renders it transparent" (185). So style can clearly change, or how we view the style, based on the audience and their situation.

If I apply Lanham's criteria to Whithaus's "ePortfolio" article from our collection, I would have to place his style between middle and high. He has clearly written his article expecting an academic audience with familiarity with writing programs. Although his writing style is comfortable, I wouldn't say that it is transparent. I know I am reading an academic article; there is no getting "lulled" into the content. The presentation is clearly formal, but cannot be characterized as artificial. I believe he is self-conscious in that he presents himself as an academician, yet the vocabulary and sentence structures are "natural" for someone in that role. He also approaches the topic from an emotional perspective in that he argues for the benefits of ePortfolios not only in writing programs but in the assessment of general education and upper division programs as well. He is obviously, then, writing for a public audience hoping for their approval or even adoption of his program. Whithaus, overall, does a good job in predicting his audience and presenting his argument.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

What is the dark side of the Web, and how does it play into your paper about style and technology?

Baron describes several drawbacks to the Web, including misrepresentation of information, misrepresentation of self, and censorship. The issue he addresses that is most closely associated with my topic though has to do with information overload.
Critics object . . . that there's too much to read in cyberspace, because so many people are filling our screens with too much text. Even if the web can't or shouldn't be censored, they argue, someone needs to sort and catalog it so that users can more easily visit the places they want to and avoid the ones they don't. (Baron 217)

When students look at a 500-600 page text dealing with grammar, usage, style, and documentation rules, it's no wonder they don't read it. They don't have a need for all of the information (at least not all at one time), and even if they did, they could never learn everything contained in the text in a semester.

In the past 10 years or so, the cultural embrace of the Web, its technology, and its visual components have caused grammar handbooks to gradually change, to mimic the Web's display or design style as best print can, assisting the reader with "sorting" important or relevant information. Baron continues, "The trick to dealing with too much information is filtering out what to ignore. To do that, we invent ways to organize reading matter, index it, and search it" (218).

The organization in these print texts follows similar designs students seem more familiar with on the Web. The introduction of tabs (similar to Windows tabs), graphics, and weblinks (like hyperlinks) allows students to quickly find the information they need without wading through pages of (what students deem) unnecessary material. "Chunking" text and creating something other than a linear layout also follows from the Web environment. These design tools assist students in the creation of a more direct and efficient path to the information they require.