Education is a kind of continuing dialogue, and a dialogue assumes, in the nature of the case, different points of view.
Robert Hutchins 1899-1977

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Thesis Attempt

This is proving to be a very challenging task for me!

For the purposes of this paper, I plan to review a selection of grammar handbooks from the 1960s to current editions (at this point, in print format only) to assess the design and layout changes afforded through computer technology and how these changes affect the reader's approach the text. I will select two or three chapters that contain similar content across time to assess the changes that occur in text structure, layout or page design, as well as the incorporation of the visual elements.My audience would be primarily composition instructors or authors considering writing a grammar handbook.

My thesis is still rough, but here's another stab:
Technology has allowed (or even encouraged) a shift in the design of grammar handbooks so that they are no longer a strictly linear, text-based medium. This evolution in design has encouraged both transformation (changes within one mode of expression, i.e. text) and transduction (transference of meaning from one mode of expression to another, i.e. text to visual) in the presentation of content within these texts providing the author with a variety of tools to create varied paths to intended meaning and readers with the power to choose their own strategies to attain the necessary information.
Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!!



Monday, March 15, 2010

Think about what you have read in Baron, Lanham, and Williams--as well as the presentations and discussions you've seen. Define style (again).

Looking back, I believe my first attempt at defining style was vague and inadequate: "Style is the form we choose or create in order to clearly present our ideas to others." Form is clearly an important aspect to style, but I think I attributed too many characteristics to what "form" entails.

Part of the reason for hedging a definition of style comes from the inherent difficulty in defining a concept that incorporates both tangible and intangible qualities. Applicable rules can be assessed: does the author's artifact conform to the audience's accepted grammatical standards or not? Other characteristics such as word choice (and the connotations conveyed), sentence structure, and voice are not so black and white. To compound matters, the application of these characteristics shifts, even with the same content, as the author's purpose and audience changes. With that said, here's my second attempt at a definition:
Style encompasses the selection of appropriate word choice and arrangement of ideas in order to relate an author's intended meaning in an accepted format to a specific audience in the clearest manner without sacrificing individuality.
Assuming an author has already selected the content to be communicated, the most important aspect pertaining to style is audience. For whom is the message intended? Jessica identified the importance of audience when she noted that style was "dictated by the field in which an author is trained or in which that author wishes to publish." While reading Eats, Shoots and Leaves, I found one of Truss's definitions of the apostrophe quite entertaining:
. . . . the apostrophe is the frantically multi-taking female, dotting hither and yon, and succumbing to burn-out from all the thankless effort. (51, illus. ed.)

Contrast this with Encarta Dictionary's definition:
the punctuation mark (') used to show where letters are omitted from a word, to mark the possessive, and sometimes to form the plural of numbers, letters, and symbols. (Web)
Clearly these definitions are intended for different audiences.

Once audience is determined, the technology authors choose to frame their work will also affect style choices. Baron emphasizes how a writer's tools force choices in how ideas are presented. With computers, authors can produce and revise indefinitely; however, when papyrus and clay were the "advanced" technologies, content and format had to be more concise and carefully planned before ideas could be written. Technologies, then, can also affect what content (or how much content) authors select and the visual layout in which to frame the content.

With these "pre-writing" decisions made, the author must then determine the importance of following convention, most closely illustrated through the clarity-brevity-sincerity approach. Although this theory can seem limiting, I think it is important to understand the basic principles put forth by Williams and others aligned with this philosophy. In Style, Williams briefly presents some rules, which are hard-fast, but focuses more on malleable characteristics or principles which lead to clarity, brevity, and sincerity in writing.

Lanham contrasts this C-B-S approach with his guiding principles of motive, play and competition, and purpose, but I do not see these approaches as exclusionary. Lanham states that "the difference between the C-B-S theory of style and the larger mixed-motive one . . . . is really the difference between being well-informed and being wise" (8). I think Williams would agree with this interpretation as he claims that "the more clearly we write, the more clearly we see and feel and think. Rules help no one do that, but some principles can" (10). Rules are important to know so authors can make informed choices about the presentation of their writing. If they opt to deviate from convention, the divergence should be both intentional and meaningful.

Despite the decisions authors must make to create their work, the effort required must not be apparent to the reader. In her first blog on style, Rhonda states that "style is a combination of the many choices we make as we write that are usually invisible to the reader." The choices authors make in structuring sentence shape, cohesion, coherence, and balance should cause the reader to "look through" (Lanham) the "artful" prose to the content.

In the end, the quality of style is judged based on the level of a thoughtful audience's engagement in the author's ideas.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

What does Baron mean by the concept of "a better pencil" and how might that impact style?

Baron's discussion of "a better pencil" is simply his exploration of how different technologies have affected writing. Before reading Baron, I had not thought of the pencil as an instrument of technology, but placing it in perspective historically, it's interesting to note the different reactions brought about by technological advances in writing tools.

Although referring specifically to the pencil, Dixon Ticonderoga's mission statement lays a foundation for how people are able to express themselves through the use of the pencil and almost any other current technological tool. People are empowered "to take conscious and subliminal thoughts--facts, ideas, dreams--and preserve them using tools that are extension of themselves" (42). It's hard to imagine the freedom and the ease people experienced when they were able to make their writing "portable," no longer tethered to a desk.

As far as how these technologies affect style, I'm not so sure. Do they making writing easier? Certainly. Computers, laptops, writing tablets, even trendy phones, all provide tools to make the generation and dissemination of ideas convenient. But ease and convenience don't always equate to better. We certainly have the means to be more prolific, but as Thoreau points out of Maine and Texas, we "may have nothing important to communicate" (33). So although technology does democratize the creation and publication of thought, it also means there is probably a considerable amount of information generated that provides limited value.

Regardless of our assessment of the content's quality, the tools we choose with which to express our thoughts definitely affect the style of our communication. Pencil and paper, even typewritten, printed text bring with it a set of conventional expectations, I think. William's principles of style seem to fit more comfortably in this setting. Moving to computers, Kindles, and iPhones with variable screen sizes and almost infinite design options, I think more goes into style than just well constructed sentences. Clarity and coherence will always be important, but they may be expressed in different ways depending on audience needs and the technology accessible to the community. Visual elements, bullets, highlighting, and hyperlinks, can aid in organization, balance, emphasis, and clarity. So, I think whatever technology we use to create and share our thoughts can't help but shape our style.

Monday, March 1, 2010

What is elegant to a technical communicator? Is that something different than what your current profession subscribes to?

I have never worked as a technical communicator, so my assessment of elegance in technical writing comes more from a consumer standpoint than that of the creator.

The difference I see between elegance in technical communication and more traditional literary or composition fields stems from the purpose of the work. Technical communicators are tasked to provide information or instruction concisely and clearly in a useful and understandable format for a user or consumer. Their task is utilitarian, for the most part. So elegance for the technical communicator is achieved through their ability to make information easily accessible to the user.

To attain this goal, tcers have a variety of tools available in addition to simple text. Where traditional academic texts use a linear format with standards fonts, point, and formatting, tcers can more easily adjust these design elements to suit the purpose of the text. In addition to creating text that conforms to William's principles, emphasis and balance can be aided through the use of color, different fonts, bullets, and other visual elements. In many documents, tcers are not confined to linear text, so graphics, charts, and tables can be incorporated to emphasize content.

Constrastingly, traditional academic writing in the composition and literature fields have a different emphasis. Although writers still have a purpose to communicate to the reader, I think nuanced writing and metaphor have more of a place here. Where a sentence like William's quotes from Mailer's stream of consciousness on page 176 may be stylistically artistic in prose, I suspect it would be unacceptable in technical writing.

In general, I think that elegance can be found in all types of writing, but the writing's purpose and the audience's needs define what is elegant for that genre.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Commentary Comments

What are the most valuable types or strategies of commentary you've seen?

For most academic assignments, I prefer direct and specific comments that clearly illustrate the strengths and weaknesses of my writing--what Lanham describes as comments that look "at" the text. That doesn't always translate into liking the comments themselves, and sometimes they are hard to read from a "feelings" standpoint, but I know that the negative feedback ("constructive criticism"??) highlights areas I need to address and weaknesses I must overcome. On the other hand, I take pride in the occasional "well written" notation and strive to model those structures or that style in future assignments. Conversational comments about the content of the text, feedback gleaned from the reader's ability to look "through" the text, are also helpful. These comments may not be as directed or specific, but notes, questions, and dialogue can still yield pragmatic and thought-provoking direction.

From a teaching standpoint, I try to provide more "looking through the text" comments with my students, but I am not always successful. The pull to the "dark side" of marking errors and making sentence level comments is sometimes difficult to overcome! Additionally, I find that many students get overwhelmed when they see a lot of writing from their instructor on the page. Many simply choose not to read feedback. In the end, I suppose I vacillate on my approach based on feedback from classes or even individual students.

As a side note, I think technology has made a difference in how I create and perceive feedback. I don't use electronic feedback frequently yet, but I like the MSWord mark-up tool. I do not know all of the intricacies of this tool, but I like how the program allows the editor to pinpoint areas and create legible comments. For me, there is something about typing the comment that seems more formal and maybe encourages me to look at a document differently. Seeing the document in print, providing feedback that will be saved electronically, knowing that no matter how many times the "delete" key is struck the comments are permanently archived somewhere makes me weigh my words more carefully. (Terrible sentence opener, I know! Maybe I'll play with it later). From the writer's standpoint, the editor's comments seem more objective and detached in some regards, and for the writer, maybe that makes them easier to read. I know they are neither detached nor mechanical, but their neat, orderly presentation seems to lend more authority than opinion. If it's in print, it must be true??

What worked or didn't work on comments offered by Dr. Rice?


I
appreciate the comments that Dr. Rice offered and the format in which they were presented. He provided some good direction for sentence level revision as well as questions and statements that will aid in content revision. The questions clearly require addressing changes in content. "Can't journals be for external audiences though?" points to an obvious void in my text. But even statements provide cause for reflection (and revision): "Perhaps; or, perhaps it is a trademark of the writer's ability to meet the needs of an audience, which is anti-individuality." I'm going to have to ponder that one!

Friday, February 12, 2010

The Importance of Style

I believe we are living in an age without style, virtue, dignity or honor. And worse than that, one in which the new is equated with the excellent…. I believe that a creator’s obligation is to filter and reflect and present in an orderly, disciplined fashion his own being. (italics mine)
Alec Wider, Letters I Never Mailed

As a developmental English instructor, I sometimes feel that the first half of Wider’s quote is accurate, but thankfully my classroom is rarely that bleak. However, his “creator’s obligation” assertion establishes a pliable framework from which to teach students how to develop and control a style of their own creation. We need for our students to understand that the style they create should be within their own control, but initially they cannot create what they do not comprehend. I purposefully chose the word “comprehend” here as I consider style a very individual and malleable entity that shifts and conforms to individual originators and their audiences; it is not a static skill to be mindlessly drilled and practiced until “mastery” is achieved. Students need a framework which acts both as a safety net and a springboard from which to leap to experiment with a variety of expressions. This allows for scaffolding, which can be constructed in various shapes, to present their ideas to their audience. Style, then, becomes a trademark of a writer’s individuality and is achieved through the successful delivery of a carefully crafted plan to specific audiences through the use of selected grammatical and rhetorical tools.

Style is not a static, private skill created and posted for the world to see. For style to have any importance to writers, we must first have formulated thoughts about something important enough for us to desire to share and affect some sort of connection with an audience. So, the first step to creating our own style is to sort out our ideas, decide what content is important, and create a framework from which to pull and sort those ideas.

Writers with the most effective sense of style are able to accomplish this through the evaluation of their audience. Who have we selected to deliver the message? What background information do they already possess, and what gaps must we fill? Even personal journal writing establishes an audience between the solitary “writers,” past and present. In The Diary of Anne Frank, Anne carries on one such conversation with herself as she relates a decision, aided by her conversation with herself within her text:
I have often been downcast, but never in despair; I regard our hiding as a dangerous adventure, romantic and interesting at the same time. In my diary I treat all the privations as amusing. I have made up my mind now to lead a different life from other girls and, later on, different from ordinary housewives. My start has been so very full of interest, and that is the sole reason why I have to laugh at the humorous side of the most dangerous moments. (Frank)
Through previous written conversations with herself, Anne demonstrates that what many students perceive as a solitary act is actually discourse, a conversation in which she engages to sort out her thoughts and beliefs.
In journal writing, audience and discourse may be easier to ascertain, but when addressing an external audience, assessing background knowledge becomes a trickier test. The most common error writers make is to give their audiences more credit than they deserve. As Benjamin Franklin is quoted in Williams’ Style (2007):
If he would inform, he must advance regularly form Things know to things unknown, distinctly without Confusion, and the lower he begins the better. It is a common Fault in Writers, to allow their Readers too much knowledge: They begin with that which should be in the Middle. . . . (p.74).

Student writers frequently make faulty assumptions in which they expect their reader to have a background and familiarity with the subject similar to their own. The inability to see the void between the audience and the subject at hand results from their own intimate relationship with the material. Encouraging students to “question” themselves as they write helps them to anticipate additional information the reader may need to make the necessary connections from the writer’s ideas to the audience’s comprehension. So another necessary aspect of style is the understanding that the selection of content must anticipate the discourse between the creator and the audience.

Next, we must devise a plan which relates our thoughts effectively to our audience. In consideration of this task, we must address both correctness and clarity. For burgeoning writers, these concepts can be difficult to balance. Correctness is a touchy characteristic, which given its overwhelming authority in most classrooms, has given it a bad name. However, correctness does have a place in defining good writing style—if kept in its place—and students need to be aware of the rules that govern their given or chosen writing environment. Before we can express style by deviating from whatever norm our audience anticipates, we must first know the norms of the community. Knowing the boundaries of what the audience considers good writing lends to both our confidence and authority as writers. Good writers who demonstrate any intentional style apply the rules of grammar—subject/verb agreement, pronoun/antecedent agreement, semi-colons—correctly which helps to demonstrate both our confidence and competence in our abilities and our knowledge of form.

But intentional deviation from some rules, the invented rules as Williams (p. 12) refers to them, does not violate any sense of good style in most audiences. We choose what form, what rules or shape, works best for the content we choose to relate, and splitting an infinitive or ending a sentence in a preposition may add more effect and deliver the material more clearly than the “correct” version of the sentence. An excerpt from William’s “Phenomenology” (1981) illustrates this point: “It may be that to fully account for the contempt that some errors of usage around, we will have to understand better than we do the relationship between language, order, and those deep psychic forces that perceived linguistic violations seem to arouse in otherwise amiable people” (p. 153). Although Williams uses the split infinitive intentionally is this article, he does this to prove the point that many, if not most readers will “miss” or “overlook” the error because they are engaged in the content—not the correctness. The difference between writers with good style and poor style though is this intentionality. Good writers choose to bend or ignore a rule when it impedes the delivery of their content.

Clarity, however, can soften the potential rigidness of correctness, but recognizing and teaching clarity has been a challenge since Aristotle’s time. He defines good prose as the following: “Let the virtue of linguistic form be defined as being clear, for since the logos is a sign, it would fail to bring about its proper function, whenever it does not make clear (whatever it is the sign of, sc.)—and neither banal/mean/flat nor above the deserved dignity, but appropriate” (Rhet. III.2, 1404b1-4, in Stanford). Aristotle, then, believed that good prose was neither “banal” nor “above the deserved dignity, but appropriate.” Simple. Maybe for Aristotle and Plato, but their attempt to create a neutral environment for communication then and today is untenable. Writing is always charged somehow because no matter what we say, our choices in content, audience, correctness, and clarity are made with a purpose.

Although this reflection on style may seem too structured to some, that the creator makes a conscious choice concerning structure is the ultimate outcome—control is ultimately in the hands of the writer. Lanham (2007) states that prose style is best when it is generated internally, when it “provides the students with a gyroscope, a compass, a map of human motive, rather than a totally planned guided tour” (p. 8). For most students, a “guided tour” is a necessary starting point. Once they discover important landmarks, however, they take side trips, both planned and unplanned based on their own interests and talents, trying different venues in which to express themselves.

For students to develop a style that will be meaningful and effective for them, they must take an active role in its creation. We, as instructors, are responsible for providing the basis from which students can make their choices, but the iterative process of planning, selecting, reflecting, and finally presenting takes a considerable amount of perseverance on the student’s part. The payoff, though, offers a style and expression all their own.

 

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Provide an example of action or character of something you've read and how that might be improved according to Williams.

Although I have run across many dense articles in my own research, reading through Williams has motivated me to create "fresh" assignments for my developmental writers. In my search for a "ready-made" example of weak writing which included nominalizations, I stumbled across this excerpt of an actual parts recall letter from an automaker:
A defect which involves the possible failure of a frame support plate may exist on your vehicle. This plate (front suspension pivot bar support plate) connects a portion of the front suspension to the vehicle frame, and its failure could affect directional control, particularly during heavy break application. In addition, your vehicle may require adjustment service to the hood secondary catch system. The secondary catch may be misaligned so that the hood may not be adequately restrained to prevent hood fly-up in the event the primary catch in inadvertently left unengaged. Sudden hood fly-up beyond the secondary catch while driving could impair driver visibility. In certain circumstances, occurrence of either of the above conditions could result in vehicle crash without prior warning.
The purpose of this letter, I suspect, dictates its intentional style--the lawyers involved in its crafting were most likely pleased with their result. However, when students mimic this style, I try to explain that their message is frequently muddled or lost. To correct or improve this sample, in addition to their text's suggestions, I also include a brief synopsis of Lanham's Paramedic Method which provides a more concise approach for this exercise. Although Lanham's process incorporates additional aspects of revision, like Williams, he encourages replacing nominalizations as well as placing the agent (character) in the subject position. Following his method, a revision of this paragraph may look like this:
Your vehicle may contain a defective front suspension pivot bar support plate. This plate connects part of the front suspension to the vehicle frame, and if you apply the brakes heavily, the plate may fail, causing you to lose control of the vehicle. Additionally, you may need to adjust the hood's secondary catch system. If the primary catch breaks, your car's hood may fly-up as a result of a misaligned secondary catch. Consequently, if the hood flys-up while you are driving, your vision could be impaired. Either of these deficiencies may cause an unexpected accident.
I'm certain this isn't a perfect revision either, but it is difficult to revise and include the intended legal style from the original version. I do, however, think this is a valuable exercise for students, and Lanham's method makes the revision process more sequential and accessible.